MILITARY TRICKS OF THE ARMY OF NESTOR MAKHNО (AUGUST- SEPTEMBER 1919) AND THE DEFENSE FORCES OF UKRAINE (AUGUST- NOVEMBER 2022) IN SOUTHERN RIGHT BANK OF UKRAINE: COMMON AND DIFFERENT

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26661/

Keywords:

Military tricks, 1919, 2022, Armed Forces of Ukraine, Cossacks, Makhnovists, South, Right-Bank Ukraine

Abstract

Military tricks are an important component of the art of war. In the history of Ukrainian military art, military tricks were particularly successfully used by Cossack formations. Ukrainian troops successfully used similar military tricks during the fight against Russian occupation troops in the South of Right Bank Ukraine (August-September 1919 and August-November 2022). In the process of analyzing military tricks, the author’s approach and methods of comparativism were used. In August-September 1919, the revolutionary insurgent army of Ukraine, led by Nestor Makhnо, defeated the Russian troops (the Red Army and the troops of the Armed Forces of Southern Rus- sia). During the fighting, the Ukrainian rebels successfully used 17 military tricks, which significantly contributed to the victory over the enemy. The Defense Forces of Ukraine successfully applied various components of mil- itary art in battles against Russian troops on the Right Bank of the Kherson region in the fall of 2022. Then the Armed Forces of Ukraine used 11 military tricks. The revolutionary insurgent army of Ukraine under the leadership of Nestor Makhno used much more military tricks, because the circumstances of the war contributed to this (maneuvering war, the talented commander Nestor Makhno, etc.). A comparison of the experience of conducting combat operations by the Ukrainian armies in August-September 1919 and August-November 2022 on the territory of the South of Right-Bank Ukraine testified to the significant similarity of the military tricks that were used. Such realities confirm not only the appropriateness of using the experience of ancestors, but also the presence of appropriate methods of Ukrainian military art and the preservation of the fighting traits of Ukrainian soldiers (initiative, self-sufficiency, combat plasticity, etc.).

References

Chop V. M., Lyman I. I. Nashchadky zaporozhtsiv: makhnovskyi rukh u Pivnichnomu Pryazovi (1918–1921 rr.). Melitopol: TOV «Vydavnychyi budynok MMD», 2019. 609 s.
Drapatyi M. «KROV DNIPROM TEChE» Khersonska nastupalna operatsiia. URL: https://mhrc.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws. com/media/files/05+%D0%9A%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2+%D0%94%D0%BD%D1%96%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0
%BC+%D1%82%D0%B5%D1%87%D0%B5.pdf
Honchar M. Selianskyi povstanskyi rukh na pivdni Ukrainy: (1918–1921 roky). Kyiv, 2007. URL: http://history.org.ua/ LiberUA/SelPovt_2007/SelPovt_2007.pdf
Makarov V. D., Pecheniuk I. S. Osoblyvosti voiennoho mystetstva povstanskoho rukhu v roky Hromadianskoi viiny (1918–1921). Voienno-istorychnyi visnyk. Kyiv, 2014. № 2(12). S. 110–117.
Savchenko V. A. Makhno. Kharkiv: Folio, 2005. 413 s.
Verstiuk V. Makhnovshchyna: selianskyi povstanskyi rukh na Ukraini (1918–1921). Kyiv: Nauk, dumka, 1992. 368 s. Voienno-istorychnyi opys rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: Vyp. 06: serpen 2022 roku / Ministerstvo oborony Ukrainy, Aparat Holovnokomanduvacha Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy, Heneralnyi shtab Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy ta Tsentr doslidzhen voiennoi istorii Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Kyiv, 2023. 176 s.
Voienno-istorychnyi opys rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: Vyp. 07: veresen 2022 roku / Ministerstvo oborony Ukrainy, Aparat Holovnokomanduvacha Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy, Heneralnyi shtab Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy ta Tsentr doslidzhen voiennoi istorii Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Kyiv, 2022. 168 s.
Voienno-istorychnyi opys rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: Vyp. 8: zhovten 2022 roku / Ministerstvo oborony Ukrainy, Aparat Holovnokomanduvacha Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy, Heneralnyi shtab Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy ta Tsentr doslidzhen voiennoi istorii Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Kyiv, 2022. 192 s.
Voienno-istorychnyi opys rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: Vyp. 9: lystopad 2022 roku / Ministerstvo oborony Ukrainy, Aparat Holovnokomanduvacha Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy, Heneralnyi shtab Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy ta Tsentr doslidzhen voiennoi istorii Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Kyiv, 2022. 164 s.
Volkovynskyi V. M. Nestor Makhno: lehendy i realnist. Kyiv: Perlit Prodakshn, LTD, 1994. 256 s. URL: https://exlibris. org.ua/machno/r07.html
Zadunaiskyi V. V. Kozatski stratehii i stratehemy pid chas kampanii 1649 r. ta yikhni analohy u «Stratehemakh» Seksta Yuliia Frontina. Istorychni i politolohichni doslidzhennia. Vinnytsia. 2018. 2 (63), S. 31–44.
Zadunaiskyi V. Kozatski viiskovi khytroshchi u bytvakh pid Khotynom i Berestechkom. Novi doslidzhennia pamiatok kozatskoi doby v Ukraini: zbirka naukovykh prats / Vidpov. red. O. M.Tytova. Vyp. 28. Kyiv: Tsentr pamiatkoznavstva NAN Ukrainy i UTOPIK, 2019. S. 189–196.
Zadunaiskyi V. V. Stratehemy Viiska Zaporozkoho ta zbroinykh formuvan Rechi Pospolytoi vprodovzh kampanii 1651 r. (na prykladi boiv pid Vinnytseiu ta Ripkamy) // Novi doslidzhennia pamiatok kozatskoi doby v Ukraini: zbirka naukovykh prats / Vidpov. red. O.M.Tytova. Vyp. 29. Nizhyn: Tsentr pamiatkoznavstva NAN Ukrainy i UTOPIK, 2020.
S. 183–190.
Zadunaiskyi V. Viiskova khytrist «zamylyty ochi» kozakiv-povstantsiv na Tamani ta makhnovtsiv na Katerynoslavshchyni v 1918 r. (za spohadamy M. Huloho, N. Makhna i V. Bilasha). Ukraina u svitovomu istorychnomu prostori: zb. materialiv

Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf., m. Mariupol, 24 kvitnia 2020 r. / pid zah. red. K. V. Balabanova. Mariupol: MDU, 2020.
S. 8–13.
Zadunaiskyi V.V. Viiskova khytrist «zaskochyty znenatska» v pershykh boiakh makhnovtsiv i kubanskykh kozakiv- povstantsiv u 1918 r. Lituanistyka i wschodoznawstwo. Poznań. Wydział Historii UAM. 2020. S. 359–369.
Zadunaiskyi V. Vymir zastosuvannia kozatskoho boiovoho i voiennoho mystetstva ukrainskymy zbroinymy formuvanniamy v 1917–1920-kh rr.: okremi aspekty. Materialy mizhnarodnoho naukovo-informatsiinoho kruhloho stolu «“KOZATSKYI FAKTOR” u suchasnii rosiisko-ukrainskii viini y dosvid XX st.». Lviv, 10 chervnia 2022 r. Lviv. Vydavnytstvo Ukrainskoho katolytskoho universytetu. 2023. S. 11–21.
Zadunaiskyi V. Viiskovi khytroshchi ukrainskykh ta rosiiskykh viisk v pershykh boiakh 2022 r. na Mykolaivshchyni ta Sumshchyni. Viiskovo-naukovyi visnyk. Lviv, 2023. Vyp. 39. S. 65–77.
Zadunaiskyi V. Stratehemy ukrainskykh i rosiiskykh viisk pid chas boiv na Chernihivshchyni (liutyi – kviten 2022 r.). Starozhytnosti Lukomoria. 2024. № 1 (22). S. 133–141.
Zadunaiskyi V. Stratagems of the Ukrainian and Russian troops in the battles for Kharkiv (February 24 – May 14, 2022). Skhid. 2023. № 5(1). P. 9–15.

Published

2025-12-05

How to Cite

MILITARY TRICKS OF THE ARMY OF NESTOR MAKHNО (AUGUST- SEPTEMBER 1919) AND THE DEFENSE FORCES OF UKRAINE (AUGUST- NOVEMBER 2022) IN SOUTHERN RIGHT BANK OF UKRAINE: COMMON AND DIFFERENT. (2025). Zaporizhzhia Historical Review, 8(60). https://doi.org/10.26661/