VYACHESLAV ZAYIKYN AS A RESEARCHER OF HISTORIOGRAPHY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26661/zhv-2024-9-61-19Keywords:
methodological reception, interwar period, scientific schools, scientific biography, historiography, Vyacheslav ZayikynAbstract
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of Vyacheslav Zayikyn’s historio-graphical contributions as a representative phenomenon of Ukrainian intellec-tual history during the interwar period. Against the backdrop of methodological explorations of the 1920s–1930s, it demonstrates how his works combine source criticism with ideological verification, aiming to overcome the imperial narrative of «unity» and integrate Ukrainian science into European discourse. The article examines Zayikyn’s early reviews of revolutionary-era memoirs, their evaluations, and his characterizations. It highlights that the sсientist identified a crisis in his-torical studies, a generational shift and changes in the criteria for evaluation of the past (a state-ethical imperative), while proposing the first typology of ideological movements: renewed populism, Christian-conservative/state and nationalist-state schools. The article separately addresses his polemic with Soviet Marxist criticism: in collaboration with O. Zayikyna, the author refuted the label of «national-fas-cism,» showcasing the ideological diversity of émigré historical-legal thought. Zayikyn’s contribution to the debate on Ukrainian ethnogenesis (polemic with M. Korduba) is analyzed: based on archaeological, anthropological, and linguistic data, he advocated for an early and autonomous trajectory of Ukrainian ethnic formation, rejecting the concept of a «all-Russian nation», distinguishing between southern (proto-Ukrainian) and northern East Slavic regions. The significance of his theoretical reflections and bibliographic work in the early 1930s, which supported scientific communication, is also demonstrated. The article concludes by emphasizing V. Zayikyn’s role as a modernizer of Ukrainian historiography, who combined strictness source criticism with conceptual thinking, promoted state approaches and opened prospects for comparative studies in intellectual history.
References
Plokhy S. Unmaking Imperial Russia: Mykhailo Hrushevsky and the Writing of Ukrainian History. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2005. 700 p.
Zayikyn V. Badania uczonych rosyjskich z dziejow spolecznych i gospodarczych 1917–1933. Rocznik Dziejow Spolecznych i Gospodarczych. 1934. Т. 3. S. 213–294.
Zayikyn V. Badania uczonych rosyjskich z dziejow spolecznych i gospodarczych 1917–1933 (Dokonczenie). Rocznik Dziejow Spolecznych i Gospodarczych. 1935. Т. 4. S. 121–224.
Dashkevych Ya. Postati: Narysy pro diiachiv istorii, polityky, kultury. Lviv: Lvivske viddilennia IUAD im. M.S. Hrushevskoho NANU, 2007. 808 s.
Dyskusiya nad pytannyam «Otkuda yest poshla ruskaya zemlya y otkuda rouskaya zemlya stala yest». Praha: Ukrayinske Istoryko-Filolohichne Tovarystvo, 1931. 30 s.
Krevetskyi I. Suchasna ukrainska istoriohrafiia. Nova Zoria. 1928. Ch. 91. S. 6.
Zayikyn V. Iskaniye smysla i tsely v istorii. Voskresnoe chtenye. 1929. № 34. S. 543–548. № 35. S. 559–562.
Zayikyn V. Ukraynskaya istoricheskaya literatura poslednikh let. Na chuzhoi storone. 1925. № 12. S. 236–251.
Zayikyn V. Ukrainskaya literatura o revoliutsii na Ukraine. Na chuzhoi storone. 1925. № 9. S. 315–320.
Zayikyn V. [retsenziia]. Literaturno-naukovyi visnyk. 1925. Ch. 1 (2). S. 85–95. Rets. na kn.: Zapysky Naukovoho Tovarystva imeni Shevchenka. Tom СХХХІV – СХХХV. Pratsi istorychno-filosofichnoi sektsii pid redaktsiieiu Ivana Krypiakevycha. Lviv, 1924. Stor. 248.
Zayikyn V. Do pytannia pro pochatok derzhavnosty u Skhidnykh Slovian. Nasha besida. 1926. № 3. S. 1–2. № 4. S. 10–11. Zayikyn V. Persha sproba systematychnoho vykladu ukrainskoi istoriografii. Zapysky tovarystva imeni Shevchenka. Pratsi Istorychno-filosofichnoi sektsii. 1926. T. 144–145. S. 225–238.
Zayikyn V. Rus, Ukraina i Velykorosiia. II. Politychni ta kulturni vzaiemyny pivdennykh (pra-ukrainskykh) i pivnichnykh skh.-slovianskykh zemel u IX-XI st. Dzvony. 1931. Ch. 2. S. 122–126. Ch. 3. S. 206–211.
Zayikyn V. Rus, Ukraina i Velykorosiia. I. Pochatky ukrainskoho i velykoruskoho narodu. Dzvony. 1931. Ch. 1. S. 19–29.
Zayikyn V. Suchasna ukrainska istorychna literatura. Ukrainska Nyva. 1926. Ch. 3–4. S. 3.
Zaikyna A., Zayikyn V. Istorychno-pravnycha nauka ukrainskoi emihratsii ta holovni ideolohichni napriamky v nii. Lviv: Persha Soiuzna Drukarnia, 1937. 19 s.
Zaikyna O., Zayikyn V. Materiialy do bibliohrafii ukrainskoi istorii 1930–1931. Zapysky chynu sv. Vasyliia Velykoho. 1935. T. VI, Vyp. 1–2. S. 327–329.
Kohut S. Yevropotsentryzm u liberalnii krytytsi Mykhaila Rudnytskoho. : dys. … kand. filol. nauk : 10.01.01. Kyiv, 2021. 213 s.
Kolossovskyi V. [Zayikyn V.]. Krizis istoricheskoho mirovozrenia. Varshavskoe ekho. 1922. 18 zhovt. S. 2–3.
Korduba M. V oboroni istorychnoi pravdy. Literaturno-naukovyi visnyk. 1931. Ch. 5. S. 424–438 .
Korduba M. Naivazhnishyi moment v istorii Ukrainy. Literaturno-naukovyi visnyk. 1930. Ch. 6. S. 539–546.
Masnenko V. Istorychna dumka ta natsiotvorennia v Ukraini (kinets XIX–persha tretyna XX st.). Kyiv; Cherkasy: Vidlunnia-Plius, 2001. 440 s.
Ohloblyn O. Pamiati akad. D I. Bahaliia. Ukraina. Zhurnal tsyklu nauk istorychnykh. 1932. Kn. 1–2. S.167–170.
Okynshevych L. Natsional-demokratychna kontseptsiia istorii prava Ukrainy v pratsiakh akad. M. Hrushevskoho. Ukraina.
Zhurnal tsyklu nauk istorychnykh. 1932. Kn. 1–2. S. 93–109.
Portnov A. Wiacheslav Zaikyn: istoryk iz bahatma oblychchiamy. Zbirnyk Kharkivskoho istoryko-filolohichnoho tovarystva.
2004. № 10. S. 89–112.
Portnov A. Istorii istorykiv: Oblychchia i obrazy ukrainskoi istoriohrafii XX stolittia. Kyiv: Krytyka, 2011. 237 s.
Sokolova L. Vnesok Wiacheslava Zaikina v istoriohrafiiu. Labirynty realnosti : zb. nauk. pr. (za materialamy V Mizhnar. naukovo-prakt. konf.), 30–31 zhovt. 2018 r. Monreal, 2018. S. 103–107.
Telvak V. Naukova diialnist Mykhaila Hrushevskoho radianskoi doby ochyma zakhidnoukrainskoi ta emihrantskoi intelihentsii.
Drohobytskyi kraieznavchyi zbirnyk. 2008. № 6–7. S. 237–252.
ISSN 

